Support Us Button Widget

Is it even Halloween without these Columbus-made candies?

Keep the candy jar local this Halloween season.

CBUStoday Anthony Thomas candy

Anthony-Thomas freshly prepares chocolates, fudge, and other sweets every day. | Photo via @anthonythomascandy

Table of Contents

When it comes to these local candy makers, there are no tricks — just treats. Follow along as we satisfy your sweet tooth with three candy-facturers in Columbus.

Anthony-Thomas Chocolates, Multiple locations

  • Hours: Monday-Saturday, 9 a.m.-8 p.m. + Sunday, 11 a.m.-5 p.m.

If you love the combination of chocolate + peanut butter from a Reese’s, stock up on buckeyes from this historic candy company that’s been in the city since 1932. Grab a buckeye box to keep at the house, or a 60-count buckeye dispenser with individually wrapped candies.

Pure Imagination Chocolatier, 1205 Grandview Ave.

  • Hours: Open everyday, 10 a.m.-8 p.m.

Come with me, and you’ll see, a world of pure imagination (and chocolate). Find handmade chocolates + build your own chocolate box with 16 options ranging from raspberry mocha truffle tor sea salted caramel. Can’t make it to the store? Let the local candy shop come to you via GrubHub.

Schmidt’s Fudge Haus, 220 S. Kossuth St.

  • Hours: Open everyday, 12-7 p.m.

From gourmet chocolate to vegan chocolate to sugar-free chocolate, everyone can get a sweet treat at this German Village shop. And, just as its name implies, its signature fudge — with flavors like rocky road — is made in-store, filling the air with delicious smells. This fudge is some of the best you’ll find; just ask Paula Deen who ranked it as her fourth best fudge in all of America.

More from CBUStoday
We asked our readers and followers where to find the best wings in Columbus, and they came through with a list of 15 spots.
We asked, and you answered. Here are the 20 pizza shops our followers and readers would choose if it was their last meal on Earth.
Putricia isn’t the only stinky flower in the world.
Hanna’s love letter to Columbus includes The Scioto Mile, the Columbus Zoo, and Ohio Stadium. What would you put in yours?
Ohio State defeated Notre Dame to win the National Championship. Explore our coverage, from player interviews to post-game celebrations.
Hanna gave her pregame predictions about each OSU football game this season, and we’ve got the final results of how she did.
Hit the slopes with skiing, snowboarding, and snow tubing this winter less than an hour from Columbus at Mad River Mountain and Snow Trails.
Columbus has an incredibly rich history that is showcased in museums throughout the area. From COSI to the Columbus Museum of Art, pay a visit to these various spots to learn all there is to know about CBUS.
From poems to nonfiction, these are our top recommendations of books written by authors based in Columbus, Ohio.