10 sandwich shops Columbus locals love

We asked CBUStoday subscribers and Instagram followers where their favorite sandwich shop in CBUS is. They came in hot with their favorite shops and go-to sandwich orders.

Screenshot 2023-12-05 at 11.50.49 AM.png

If you love a classic Italian sandwich, this is for you. | Photo by @cravingscafe614

Table of Contents

When it comes to a quality bite, these sandwich shops get it right. Chow down on 10 places our readers and followers swear by.

Cravings Cafe, 114 N Front St.

“The Vegginator” is a top pick, made with honey goat cheese, Brussels sprout apple slaw, red onions, tomato, and lettuce.

The Brown Bag Delicatessen, 898 Mohawk St.

Reader Kayln M. told us, “My go-to order rotates between #7 The Village Addiction and #16 Classic Club. It’s the specialty mayo’s that make these sandwiches.”

Club 185, 185 E. Livingston Ave.

“On Thursdays at Club 185 they serve a roast beef sandwich that is hands down the best sandwich in Central Ohio,” said reader Duane H.

Screenshot 2023-12-05 at 11.48.05 AM.png

The Buffalo style “Beef on Weck” is a Thursday special. | Photo by @club_285

Emmett’s Cafe, Multiple locations

Our followers suggest “The Emmything” — a matija everything roll with rosemary aioli, grilled chicken, white cheddar, prosciutto, roasted red pepper, and arugula.

Loops, 1629 Northwest Blvd.

This family-owned shop and food truck was featured on “Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives” twice. The sandwiches are served on grilled pita or hoagies.

Uptown Deli & Brew, 41 N. State St.

Find signature sandwiches like roast beef, smoked salmon, Tuscan turkey, and pimento grilled cheese at this European-style deli in Westerville.

Screenshot 2023-12-05 at 12.22.12 PM.png

Would you try a mac and cheese loaded grilled cheese sandwich? | Photo by @meltbargrilled

Melt Bar and Grilled, 4206 Worth Ave.

This Ohio-based chain has an Easton location, and is the go-to spot for grilled cheese lovers.

Cornerstone Deli & Cafe, 3296 N. High St.

Choose a hot classic like the pizza bagel or a cold classic like the B.L.T. Breakfast sandwiches and wraps are also available.

The Thurman Cafe, 183 Thurman Ave.

Sandwiches range from fish to buffalo chicken to corned beef. Bonus: Hot subs are also available.

Frenchi’s Deli, 18 E Hudson St.

Sandwiches are made on hoagies or rye bread and wrap options are garlic and herbs or tomato basil.

More from CBUStoday