Support Us Button Widget

10 sandwich shops Columbus locals love

We asked CBUStoday subscribers and Instagram followers where their favorite sandwich shop in CBUS is. They came in hot with their favorite shops and go-to sandwich orders.

Screenshot 2023-12-05 at 11.50.49 AM.png

If you love a classic Italian sandwich, this is for you. | Photo by @cravingscafe614

Table of Contents

When it comes to a quality bite, these sandwich shops get it right. Chow down on 10 places our readers and followers swear by.

Cravings Cafe, 114 N Front St.

“The Vegginator” is a top pick, made with honey goat cheese, Brussels sprout apple slaw, red onions, tomato, and lettuce.

The Brown Bag Delicatessen, 898 Mohawk St.

Reader Kayln M. told us, “My go-to order rotates between No. 7 The Village Addiction and No. 16 Classic Club. It’s the specialty mayo’s that make these sandwiches.”

Club 185, 185 E. Livingston Ave.

“On Thursdays at Club 185 they serve a roast beef sandwich that is hands down the best sandwich in Central Ohio,” said reader Duane H.

Screenshot 2023-12-05 at 11.48.05 AM.png

The Buffalo style “Beef on Weck” is a Thursday special. | Photo by @club_285

Emmett’s Cafe, Multiple locations

Our followers suggest “The Emmything” — a matija everything roll with rosemary aioli, grilled chicken, white cheddar, prosciutto, roasted red pepper, and arugula.

Loops, 1629 Northwest Blvd.

This family-owned shop and food truck was featured on “Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives” twice. The sandwiches are served on grilled pita or hoagies.

Uptown Deli & Brew, 41 N. State St.

Find signature sandwiches like roast beef, smoked salmon, Tuscan turkey, and pimento grilled cheese at this European-style deli in Westerville.

Screenshot 2023-12-05 at 12.22.12 PM.png

Would you try a mac and cheese loaded grilled cheese sandwich? | Photo by @meltbargrilled

Melt Bar and Grilled, 4206 Worth Ave.

This Ohio-based chain has an Easton location, and is the go-to spot for grilled cheese lovers.

Cornerstone Deli & Cafe, 3296 N. High St.

Choose a hot classic like the pizza bagel or a cold classic like the B.L.T. Breakfast sandwiches and wraps are also available.

The Thurman Cafe, 183 Thurman Ave.

Sandwiches range from fish to buffalo chicken to corned beef. Bonus: Hot subs are also available.

Frenchi’s Deli, 18 E Hudson St.

Sandwiches are made on hoagies or rye bread and wrap options are garlic and herbs or tomato basil.

More from CBUStoday
Prepare for winter in CBUS with these seasonal temperature and precipitation outlooks.
The local rental home has fire pits, a hot tub, and scenic views to escape the city life and dive into a relaxing staycation.
From dog parks to donut shops, here’s where our Instagram followers suggest to shop locally on Saturday, Nov. 30 for Small Business Saturday.
Check out winter and holiday-themed events happening in Columbus with our seasonal guide.
Including gifts for neighbors, foodies, significant others, homebodies, students, and gifts under $20.
Check out some of the coolest, most unique Airbnb and Vrbo rentals around Columbus and plan for your next adventure or staycation.
Check out these 12 yoga studios around CBUS, which offer everything from hot yoga to classes for beginners to outdoor options.
Check out our guide to the many meaningful murals you can find around Columbus.
Prepare for fall weather in CBUS with these seasonal temperature and precipitation outlooks.