16 pizza places the locals love

We’ve already brought you pizza superlatives featuring everything from Columbus-style pizza to the most unique toppings. But this time, we asked you where you’d grab a local slice if it was your last meal on Earth. Here are the 16 pizza places you chose...

🍕 Harvest Pizzeria, Multiple locations

• Grab a pie in Clintonville, Dublin, Bexley, and the Brewery District.

🍕 GoreMade Pizza, 936 N. 4th St.

• Order a wood-fired pizza with a variety of toppings.

🍕 Mikey’s Late Night Slice, Multiple locations

• Try rotating unique toppings like mac and cheese.

🍕 The Pizza House, 747 E. Lincoln Ave.

• Grab a homemade pie from this downtown spot.

🍕 Yellow Brick, Multiple locations

• Build your own 10, 14, or 16-inch pizza.

🍕 Brenz Pizza Co., Multiple locations

• Order from Columbus, Dublin, or New Albany.

🍕 Enrico’s Pizza & Restaurant, 5788 Frantz Rd.

• Find everything from anchovies to hamburger pizza.

🍕 JT’s Pizza, Pub, & Patio, 2390 W. Dublin Granville Rd.

• Choose crusts like cajun, garlic butter, and sesame seed.

🍕 Dante’s Pizza, 3586 Indianola Ave.

• Try a meatball or zucchini pizza.

🍕 Paulie Gee’s, 1195 N. High St.

• This Short North spot has a wide range of wood-fired options.

🍕 Hounddog’s Pizza, 2657 N. High St.

• Our Instagram followers recommended the smokin’ Joe’s crust.

🍕 Tommy’s Pizza, Multiple locations

• This classic pizza spot has been in Columbus since 1952.

🍕 Pasquale’s Pizza & Pasta House, 558 W. Schrock Rd.

• Order specialty pizzas like breakfast and buffalo chicken.

🍕 Plank’s Cafe & Pizzeria, 743 Parsons Ave.

• Find fresh pizzas topped with chipotle ranch.

🍕 Antonio’s Pizzeria & Restaurant, 7001 Sunbury Rd. #C

• This pizza spot has been in Uptown Westerville since 1977.

🍕 Gatto’s Pizza, 3420 Indianola Ave.

• Gatto’s is known for its Columbus-style, thin crust pizza.

Did we miss your favorite spot? Let us know so we can include it next time.