We aren’t letting this rest any longer — here are the 12 best bakeries in Columbus, according to our readers and followers.
Auddino’s Italian Bakery, 1490 Clara St.
Everything is made in-house at this bakery that offers Italian treats like cannolis, and provides sub buns to many popular pizzerias in the area.
Bake Me Happy, Multiple locations
Stop by the southside or Dublin location for gluten-free cakes, cookies, donuts, muffins, and brownies.
Belle’s Bread, 1168 Kenny Centre Mall
Pick up a variety of Japanese-style baked goods, including rolls, sweet bread, and donuts.
Dan the Baker, 1028 Ridge St.
This bakery features a rotating menu, with options such as sesame bread, baguettes, and almond croissants.
Dough Mama, 3335 N. High St.
Stop by this Clintonville shop for gluten-free peanut butter cookies, vegan ginger molasses cookies, and cheddar scallion biscuits.
Fox in the Snow, Multiple locations
Everything on the menu is prepared in-house, ranging from the baguette sandwiches to the blueberry galette.
Kittie’s Cafe, 495 S. 3rd St.
When a place dubs itself as the best cinnamon rolls in Columbus, you don’t mess around.
Matt’s Bakery, 39 Yearling St.
This bakery specializes in challah with full sizes and rolls as well.
Omega Artisan Baking, 59 Spruce St.
This North Market bakery freshly prepares rustic breads like baguettes and sourdough + offers favorites like the pepperoni roll.
Pattycake Bakery, 3870 N. High St.
Browse a selection of seasonal vegan and gluten-free options such as sticky buns, cookies, and cupcakes.
Pistacia Vera, 541 S. 3rd St.
Pair your fresh croissant, macaron, or cookie with one of their seasonal drinks, such as the pumpkin latte.
Resch’s Bakery, 4061 E. Livingston Ave.
Keep your birthday or wedding cake local with this popular bakery that has been in Columbus since 1912.